Help me find a caterer

Dear Readers,

I need your help! We are planning our wedding for late October in New York City. We've secured a venue for the ceremony and a reception site, but we are still in search of a caterer. We are planning a cocktails and hors d'oeuvres reception for 40-50 guests, and have a budget of $75 per person for all catering related expenses.

Do you know of a caterer you'd recommend who can work within that budget? If so, please leave a comment! Have cost-cutting suggestions? Leave a comment! Think we're totally out of our minds? Leave a comment! Any and all advice and recommendations gladly accepted, and I'll collect all suggestions into a new post. Thanks for your help!